• Students
  • Alumni
  • Faculty
  • Staff
  • Community
  • QUICK LINKS
  • DIRECTORY
  • APPLY
  • GIVE
  • RENT
Hunter College
About
  • Overview
  • Focus on Campus
  • Mission
  • Strategic Plan
  • Leadership
  • Campus Information
  • Contact Us
Academics
  • Approach
  • Provost
  • Schools
  • Majors
  • Honors & Scholars
  • Education Abroad
  • Advising
  • Research & Creative Works
  • Course Catalogs
  • Accreditation
Admissions
  • Overview
  • Undergraduate
  • Graduate
  • Course Catalogs
Student Life
  • Clubs & Organizations
  • Residence Life
  • Athletics
  • Dining On Campus
  • Community
  • Events
  • News
  • Libraries
Hunter College Schools
  • Arts & Sciences
  • Education
  • Health Professions
  • Urban Public Health
  • Nursing
  • Silberman School of Social Work
More Schools
  • Hunter College Campus Schools
  • Hunter College Continuing Education
  • Libraries
  • Students
  • Alumni
  • Faculty
  • Staff
  • Community
  • Events
  • News
  • APPLY
  • GIVE
  • RENT
  • QUICK LINKS
  • DIRECTORY

Hunter Community: We are pleased to report that the Hunter email and Wi-Fi systems are now back in service. To access these Hunter systems, you will need to reset your NetID password. Please go to the Hunter website for instructions on how to reset your password. CUNYFirst, Blackboard, student email and Zoom continue to be available and DO NOT require a password change. We continue to work diligently to bring all other affected systems back online. Again, we apologize for this interruption in service. Please continue to check the website and maintain access to CUNY Alerts for additional updates. Thank you again for your ongoing patience.

News /

Hunter College Study Finds 7.5 Obstructions Per 10 City Blocks

December 20, 2019
Share
bike lane

New research conducted by Hunter College students and their professors provides a snapshot of New York City’s growing bicycle culture and the risks cyclists face due to obstructions.

The new study, “Bike Lanes or Blocked Lanes: An Observational Study of Obstructions of New York City’s Bike Lanes,” directed by Hunter Sociology Professors Peter Tuckel and Kate Pok-Carabalona, quantifies the different types of obstructions found in bike lanes throughout New York City, except Staten Island.

Several important findings emerged in this study. First, obstructions in bike lanes in New York City are a frequent occurrence, with an average of 7.5 obstructions per 10 city blocks or approximately 11.5 obstructions per mile.  The two leading types of obstructions were pedestrians and motorized vehicles.  Overall, there were approximately 3 pedestrian and 3 vehicular obstructions per 10-block range. The third most frequent type of obstruction was construction.  The number of impediments due to construction was .66 per 10-block range, or about 1 per mile.

“This last statistic is a particularly troubling one,” said Professor Tuckel.  “While pedestrian and most vehicular obstructions were transitory in nature, construction sites, by definition, are more enduring and are a major disruption and danger to cyclists.”

The study examines two types of bike lanes. Conventional bike lanes are those that have a bicycle logo painted on them at various intervals and have solid painted lines on both sides delineating their boundaries.  Protected bike lanes are demarcated by either wide buffered areas or physical barriers separating them from vehicular traffic.  Omitted from the study are “Shared Lanes,” in which motorized vehicles and bikes occupy the same street space, and “Signed Routes,” which simply designate a suggested route for cyclists. The study also excludes bike lanes straddling bridges.

“As would be expected, motorized vehicular obstructions were less common in protected than conventional bike lanes.  Nevertheless, cyclists riding in protected bike lanes still confront an array of obstacles,” said Tuckel.

Somewhat surprisingly, the average number of obstructions of all types in protected bike lanes exceeded the number in conventional bike lanes (8.5 vs. 6.8). According to Professor Pok-Carabalona, the data show that the number of pedestrian obstructions in protected bike lanes greatly outpaces the corresponding number in conventional bike lanes, and other obstructions also figured more prominently in protected bike lanes than in conventional bike lanes.

“We found that while pedestrians walking in or crossing into the bike lanes constituted the most numerous obstacles, other obstructions—such as people walking their dogs or riding scooters, and cyclists going against the flow of traffic or in the wrong designated direction of the bike lane—were much greater in the protected lanes than the conventional bike lanes,” said Pok-Carabalona. “The numbers show that obstructions in bike lanes are ubiquitous and pose a significant safety hazard to cyclists, not to mention to those committing the obstructions. If bike lanes, and particularly protected bike lanes, are for providing cyclists a safe environment in which to ride, then solutions need to be found to eliminate the myriad number of obstacles that impede cyclists riding in these lanes.”

In addition, the study found, as expected, that the average number of obstructions in Manhattan per 10-block street range was greater than the average number in the other three studied boroughs (8.1 vs. 6.8).  There was also a higher incidence of obstructions in weekday peak hours than in weekday off-peak hours (8.5 vs. 5.8).

The study authors also found that protected bike lanes are more popular than conventional bike lanes by a margin of 4.5 to 1. These numbers were consistent no matter the borough, the day of the week, or the time of day.  While these numbers could be due to protected bike lanes straddling arterial roads and conventional bike lanes running alongside less major routes, members of the New York City cycling community have repeatedly voiced their preference for protected bike lanes. This finding also accords with previous research showing a decided preference for protected bike lanes by cyclists.

The study also measured the number of cyclists against the days of the week and times of day.  The average number of cyclists counted per 15-minute interval riding on Saturday or Sunday slightly exceeded the number counted during peak weekday hours (23 vs. 21), underscoring cycling’s importance as a healthy form of recreation—and not just an environmentally friendly alternative means of transportation.

The observational study was carried out by Hunter College students enrolled in one of three different courses in the fall semester of 2019. Two were undergraduate-level courses offered in the Department of Sociology (two sections of Introduction to Research Methods).  The third was a graduate-level course also offered in the Department of Sociology (Intermediate Statistics).

“For more than 20 years, Professor Tuckel has provided students with research skills that can be used in the workplace and created new knowledge that improves life in New York City,” said Jennifer J. Raab, President of Hunter College. “As 2020—our 150th anniversary—approaches, we look forward to celebrating Hunter’s legacy of scholarship and community service, as well as our vital place at the center of New York’s academic and cultural life.”

Each student or pair of students was assigned a bike lane from which they selected a 10-block street range.  The students visited these 10-block street ranges on two separate occasions. They were instructed to visit their sites during one “peak time” and one “off-peak time.”  Peak times included weekdays either from 7:00 am to 9:30 am or from 4:30 pm to 6:30 pm. Off-peak times consisted of weekdays between 9:31 am and 4:29 pm or between 7:00 am and 6:30 pm on Saturday or Sunday. All observations were carried out between September 20 and October 27, 2019.

LEARN ABOUT RESEARCH

READ
stories about innovation
EXPLORE
our research efforts
GIVE
to support our college
Read the Full Study Here
PreviousNext

Office of Communications
for media information and more
student with vaccination
Get Vaccinated

CUNY's vaccination policy requires all students to get vaccinated for all hybrid and in-person classes.

Read CUNY's FAQs

student watching online event
Hunter on Demand

Enjoy virtual lectures, discussions and readings by members of Hunter’s distinguished faculty.

Join Us

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Flickr

NEWS SPOTLIGHT

May 10, 2022
Hunter Crossroads—Lexington Ave and 68th St.— Named ‘Audre Lorde Way’

“It’s a singular honor for us to commemorate one of our most distinguished and influential alums,” said President Raab of the legendary warrior poet.

April 25, 2022
Three From Hunter College are Named 2022 Guggenheim Fellows

Professor Lisa Corinne Davis and alumni Ellie Ga and Keliy Anderson-Staley are among 180 scientists, writers, scholars, and artists honored.

See All Spotlight News

EVENTS CALENDAR

Mar 19, 2022 through Jun 4, 2022
Ademola Olugebefola: Afrofuturist

Hallway Exhibition - Ademola Olugebefola: Afrofuturist While the term Afrofuturism dates only to the 1990s, musicians, writers, playwrights, and ...

Mar 23, 2022 through Jun 30, 2022
Sanctuary City Three Artists Explore the Refugee Experience in New York City

Sanctuary City: Three Artists Explore the Refugee Experience in New York City is an exhibition that looks at three artists— Shimon Attie, ...

See All Featured Events

HUNTER

Hunter College
695 Park Ave NY, NY 10065
212-772-4000

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Flickr
  • ABOUT
  • ACADEMICS
  • ADMISSIONS
  • EVENTS
  • NEWS
Hunter College Schools
  • Arts & Sciences
  • Education
  • Health Professions
  • Urban Public Health
  • Nursing
  • Silberman School of Social Work
  • Arts & Sciences
  • Education
  • Health Professions
  • Urban Public Health
  • Nursing
  • Silberman School of Social Work
Our Other Schools
  • Hunter College Campus Schools
  • Hunter College Continuing Education
  • Hunter College Campus Schools
  • Hunter College Continuing Education
Hunter College Libraries
More Info
  • Bookstore
  • Contact Us & Feedback
  • Jobs
  • Public Safety
  • Roosevelt House
  • Student Housing
  • Space Rentals
  • Bookstore
  • Contact Us & Feedback
  • Jobs
  • Public Safety
  • Roosevelt House
  • Student Housing
  • Space Rentals
Public Information
  • Annual Security & Fire Safety Report
  • Consumer Information
  • CUNY Tobacco Policy
  • Enough is Enough
  • Focus on Campus
  • Annual Security & Fire Safety Report
  • Consumer Information
  • CUNY Tobacco Policy
  • Enough is Enough
  • Focus on Campus
CUNY
  • © 2022 Hunter College
  • Accessibility
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy
  • Terms